All Clad vs Scanpan: Which Cookware Brand is Better?

If you are looking for high-quality cookware that can handle any cooking task, you might have come across two popular brands: All-Clad and Scanpan. These brands offer a range of cookware sets designed to last for years and deliver excellent performance. But how do they compare? Which one is better for your kitchen and your cooking style? In this article, we will review the features, pros, and cons of All-Clad and Scanpan cookware and help you decide the best choice.

ALL-CLAD COOKWARE

John Ulam, a metallurgist who developed a method of joining several metals to make better cookware, launched the US-based firm All-Clad in 1971. For its fully-clad stainless steel cookware, which features an aluminum or copper core sandwiched between layers of stainless steel, All-Clad is well-known. The durability, resistance to warping, and corrosion are all guaranteed by this structure. Additionally, All-Clad cookware is dishwasher, induction, oven, and broiler safe.

All-Clad HA1 Hard Anodized Nonstick Cookware Set

One of All-Clad’s most popular cookware sets is the HA1 Hard Anodized Nonstick Cookware Set. This set includes 10 pieces of hard-anodized aluminum cookware with a 3-layer PTFE nonstick coating. The hard-anodized aluminum is strong, lightweight, and scratch-resistant, while the nonstick coating allows easy food release and cleanup. The set also features riveted stainless steel handles for stability and stay cool on the stovetop. The lids are tempered glass that lets you monitor the cooking process without losing heat or moisture. The set includes:

• 8-inch fry pan
• 10-inch fry pan
• 2.5-quart saucepan with lid
• 3.5-quart saucepan with lid
• 4-quart sauté pan with lid
• 8-quart stockpot with lid

SCANPAN COOKWARE

Olav Holm Larsen, a metalworker who wished to provide better cookware for his wife, created the Danish firm Scanpan in 1956. Scanpan is renowned for its innovative titanium-infused ceramic nonstick coatings.

These coatings are extremely durable, scratch-resistant, and PFOA-free. They can withstand high temperatures and metal utensils without peeling or flaking. Scanpan cookware is also made of squeeze-cast aluminum or stainless steel-clad aluminum, which ensures fast and even heat conduction. Scanpan cookware is also oven-safe, dishwasher-safe, and induction-compatible.

Scanpan Classic 8-Piece Cookware Set

One of the most popular cookware sets from Scanpan is the Classic 8 Piece Cookware Set. This set includes 8 pieces of squeeze-cast aluminum cookware with a 5-layer STRATANIUM nonstick coating. The squeeze-cast aluminum is dense, strong, and warp-resistant, while the STRATANIUM coating offers superior searing performance and easy food release. The set also features riveted ergonomic handles for security and stay cool on the stovetop. The lids are made of stainless steel that seals in heat and moisture. The set includes:

• 8-inch fry pan
• 10.25-inch fry pan
• 2-quart saucepan with lid
• 3-quart saucepan with lid
• 6.5-quart Dutch oven with lid

ALL-CLAD VS. SCANPAN: COMPARISON

Now that we have introduced the two brands and their popular cookware sets let’s compare them in terms of design and construction, material, heat distribution, nonstick coating, maintenance, and pros and cons.

Building and Design

All-Clad and Scanpan cookware has a sleek and modern design that will look great in any kitchen. They both have sturdy handles that are comfortable to hold and easy to maneuver. They both have tight-fitting lids that lock in heat and moisture. However, there are some differences in their construction.

All-Clad cookware is fully-clad, meaning the core material extends to the rim of the pan. This ensures even heat distribution throughout the entire surface of the pan. Scanpan cookware is clad only on the base, which means that the core material covers only the bottom of the pan. This ensures fast heat conduction on the base but not on the sides.

All-Clad cookware has a stainless steel exterior polished to a mirror finish. This gives it a shiny and elegant appearance and makes it prone to fingerprints and stains. Scanpan cookware has an aluminum exterior that is hard-anodized to a matte finish. This gives it a dark and sleek appearance but also makes it resistant to scratches and stains.

Material

Both All-Clad and Scanpan cookware are made of high-quality materials that are durable and safe for cooking. However, they use different metals for their core and cooking surface.

All-Clad cookware has a core of aluminum or copper, depending on the collection. Aluminum is a lightweight and excellent heat conductor, while copper is a heavier and superior heat conductor. Both metals can heat up and cool down quickly, which gives you precise temperature control. 

However, both metals are also reactive, so they can react with acidic foods and alter their flavor and color. That’s why All-Clad cookware has a layer of stainless steel on the interior and exterior of the pan. Stainless steel is a non-reactive and durable metal that can withstand high temperatures and corrosion. However, stainless steel is also a poor heat conductor, which can create hot spots and uneven heating. That’s why All-Clad cookware needs a thick core of aluminum or copper to compensate for the low thermal conductivity of stainless steel.

Scanpan cookware has a core of aluminum, regardless of the collection. Aluminum is a lightweight and excellent heat conductor, as mentioned before. However, aluminum is also a soft and reactive metal, which can dent easily and react with acidic foods. That’s why Scanpan cookware has a layer of ceramic on the interior and exterior of the pan. Ceramics is a non-reactive and hard material that can withstand high temperatures and abrasion. 

Ceramic, however, conducts heat poorly, leading to hot patches and uneven heating. Due to the limited heat conductivity of ceramic, Scanpan cookware requires a thick core of aluminum.

Heat Distribution

Thanks to their thick aluminum cores, all-Clad and Scanpan cookware have excellent heat distribution. However, there are some differences in how they perform on different heat sources.

All-Clad cookware is compatible with all stovetops, including gas, electric, ceramic, halogen, and induction. It can also be used in the oven and broiler up to 600°F. However, All-Clad cookware is unsuitable for high heat, as it can damage the nonstick coating or cause the stainless steel to discolor or warp. Using low to medium heat for most cooking tasks is recommended, and preheat the pan before adding oil or food.

Scanpan cookware is also compatible with all stovetops, including gas, electric, ceramic, halogen, and induction. It can also be used in the oven up to 500°F. However, Scanpan cookware is suitable for high heat, as it can handle temperatures up to 850°F without damaging the nonstick coating or causing the aluminum to warp. It is recommended to use high heat for searing and browning and lower the heat after adding oil or food.

Nonstick Coating

All-Clad and Scanpan cookware have nonstick coatings, making cooking and cleaning easier. However, they use different types of nonstick materials that have different properties.

All-Clad cookware has a 3-layer PTFE nonstick coating on the stainless steel surface. PTFE stands for polytetrafluoroethylene, a synthetic polymer with very low friction and high resistance to heat and chemicals. 

PTFE is also known as Teflon, a trademark name of Chemours (formerly DuPont). PTFE nonstick coatings are very effective at preventing food from sticking to the pan, but they also have some drawbacks. PTFE nonstick coatings can degrade over time due to exposure to high temperatures or abrasive cleaning agents. They can also release toxic fumes if overheated above 500°F, which can cause flu-like symptoms in humans or death in birds. PTFE nonstick coatings are also not very durable or scratch-resistant, meaning they can peel or flake off if scratched by metal utensils or abrasive cleaners.

Scanpan cookware has a 5-layer STRATANIUM nonstick coating fused with the aluminum surface. STRATANIUM stands for strontium titanium aluminate, a ceramic material with very high hardness and resistance to heat and abrasion. STRATANIUM is a patented technology developed by Scanpan after years of research and testing. 

STRATANIUM nonstick coatings are very effective at preventing food from sticking to the pan, but they also have some advantages over PTFE nonstick coatings. STRATANIUM nonstick coatings do not degrade over time due to exposure to high temperatures or abrasive cleaning agents. They do not release toxic fumes if overheated above 500°F, making them safe for humans and birds. STRATANIUM nonstick coatings are also very durable and scratch-resistant, which means they can withstand metal utensils and abrasive cleaners without peeling or flaking off.

Maintenance

All-Clad and Scanpan cookware are easy to maintain, as they have nonstick coatings that make cleaning a breeze. However, there are differences in how they should be cared for to prolong their lifespan and performance.

Because All-Clad cookware is dishwasher safe, you can easily and quickly clean it up by putting it in the dishwasher. However, it is advised to hand-wash it in warm water with a mild soap to retain the stainless steel sheen and nonstick coating. Using abrasive cleaners, scouring pads, or steel wool should also be avoided since they may harm the stainless steel surface’s finish or destroy the nonstick coating. After cleaning, be sure to completely dry the cookware to avoid water stains or rusting.

If the cookware develops discoloration or stains, you can use a stainless steel cleaner or vinegar to restore its shine. Scanpan cookware is also dishwasher-safe, meaning you can put it in the dishwasher for a quick and convenient cleanup. However, it is recommended to hand-wash it with hot water and mild soap to preserve the nonstick coating and the hard-anodized finish. 

You should also avoid using harsh detergents, scouring pads, or steel wool, as they can damage the nonstick coating or scratch the aluminum surface. You should also dry the cookware thoroughly after washing to prevent water spots or corrosion. If the cookware develops any food residue or stains, you can use a nylon brush or a baking soda paste to remove them.

All-Clad: The Pros and Cons

This section will explore the advantages and potential drawbacks of choosing All-Clad cookware for your kitchen.

Scanpan: The Pros and Cons

This section will discuss the advantages and disadvantages of choosing Scanpan cookware.

ALL-CLAD VS. SCANPAN: WHICH IS THE BEST?

As you can see, All-Clad and Scanpan cookware have pros and cons, and there is no clear winner between them. The best choice for you depends on your preferences, cooking style, budget, and needs. Here are some factors that might help you decide which one is the best for you:

• If you prefer a fully-clad construction that ensures even heat distribution throughout the entire surface of the pan, you might prefer All-Clad cookware.
• If you prefer a clad base construction that ensures fast heat conduction on the bottom of the pan, you might prefer Scanpan cookware.
• If you prefer a stainless steel exterior that is polished to a mirror finish, which gives it a shiny and elegant appearance, you might prefer All-Clad cookware.
• If you prefer an aluminum exterior that is hard-anodized to a matte finish, which gives it a dark and sleek appearance, you might prefer Scanpan cookware.
• You might prefer All-Clad cookware if you prefer a 3-layer PTFE nonstick coating that allows for easy food release and cleanup.
• If you prefer a 5-layer STRATANIUM nonstick coating with superior searing performance and easy food release, you might prefer Scanpan cookware.
• If you prefer cookware compatible with all stovetops, including induction, you might like All-Clad and Scanpan cookware, as they are both induction-compatible.
• If you prefer oven-safe cookware and broiler-safe up to 600°F, you might prefer All-Clad cookware.
• If you prefer oven-safe cookware up to 500°F, you might prefer Scanpan cookware.
• If yoSupposeprefer cookware with a lifetime warranty covering any defects in materials or quality, you. In that case, you might like All-Clad and Scanpan cookware, as they offer lifetime warranties.

CONCLUSION

In conclusion, All-Clad and Scanpan cookware are high-quality brands offering a range of cookware sets designed to last for years and deliver excellent performance. However, they also have some differences in design and construction, material, heat distribution, nonstick coating, maintenance, and pros and cons. 

Your tastes, cooking style, demands, and financial situation will determine which option is ideal for you. To learn more about other people’s experiences and opinions after purchasing and using the items, you may also read customer reviews on Amazon. You can compare All-Clad and Scanpan cookware in this post to help you determine which is ideal for you. Have fun cooking! 

FAQs